The Woman
Warrior: Memoirs of a Girlhood Among Ghosts follows author Maxine Hong
Kingston's memories of growing up as a child of Chinese
immigrants in San Francisco. The story is written in first narrative. The author not only provides a
voice for herself but also for other immigrants like her who did not had the
opportunity to speak out and tell their stories. Most importantly, the
story indicates an important issue for most immigrants---the cultural
difference.
I’m the first generation immigrant coming
with my family to America three years ago. I came to study in a community
college in Seattle. As a Chinese, I can see myself in The Woman Warrior. Maxine felt very uncomfortable when talking in
English with others. “I stand frozen, or
I hold up the line with the complete, grammatical sentence that comes squeaktng
out at impossible length.” I had the
same feeling with Maxine. I had a statistic class in my first quarter in
college. Every week, we had one discussion class. The instructor will choose
some students randomly to teach other students one statistic question. Although
those questions were not difficult to me, I felt like a dummy when I stand in
front of the whole class. When there
were some students still confused about that question and kept asking me some
questions which I couldn’t find proper vocabularies in English to answer, just
like Maxine, I stand frozen, and my brain went empty. Maxine also mentioned
that everytime people asked her to repeat what she said, her voice got weaker
and finally she was unwilling to talk to some one else. I can definitely understand
her. That makes me feel that I’m different with other people, and I feel embarrassed
about it. Maxine’s situation reveals an important problem immigrants usually
face---language. Language is the basic tool for living in a society, and it’s
also an obstacle for immigrants to integrate into the local society. How can a
person live a happy life if he/she can’t state his/her own thoughts well? English
is not our first language. We use Chinese at the time we were born. Even though
I studied English in China for more than ten years, my way to think and arrange
my words is still in Chinese mode. Our homeland’s language is our cultural
root. It’s impossible to change our language habit immediately, therefore, more
importantly, we should have a better mentality when we face those language
problems. Just like Maxine says “I am making progress, a little every day.”
The story also states an immigration
problem—tradition. There is one plot talking about the narrator’s mother
wants her to get “revenge” from drugstore for their mistake in one wrong
delivery of drug. She is so angry when "he had a pale blue box of pills,
but nobody was sick". Her mother cursed the delivery boy to be "the
dead ghost", and says "how dare he come to the wrong house?"
She believes the wrong delivery of drug is a curse and a crime, and she says it’s
Maxine’s fault if Maxine doesn’t go to the drug shop and get back some reparation
candy. Even as a Chinese, I would say this is very ridiculous, but still, it’s
a Chinese tradition that agreed with many old Chinese people. People in the
drug store, who grow up with the American culture would treat this as insanity.
Like most immigrants, Maxine is stuck between the Chinese culture and American
culture. It’s hard to transfer from one culture to another culture, but Maxine
made a change. She let the drugstore think she is poor, and get the candy
successfully. As immigrants, we can understand our own traditions, but it’s
impossible let other people in USA understand them. Personally, I would say Maxine’s
choice is smart but a little sad, because from another aspect, she can’t keep
all of her cultural identity. In order to integrate into local society,
immigrants have to change some cultural traditions. I used to celebrate every
traditional festival with my family in China, but after we come here, there’s
no vocation for celebrating those festivals, and we can do is only to accept
the change.
Maxine had a very hard time to integrate
into the American society, and I sympathize with the suffering in her
childhood. However, if I’m the author, I might have a different story to tell.
The narrator in my story wouldn’t suffer so much as hers. Her story was written
in 1976, almost 50 years ago. Things have changed so much today. Although
immigrants still face some problems about culture shock, the huge gap between
each culture is decreasing gradually. Globalization and technology is changing
the world. 50 years ago, when immigrants met some language difficulty, they can
do nothing but find the paper dictionary, but we have iphone and laptop today.
50 years ago, American people maybe do not understand Asian culture at all, but
today some American people can say fluently Chinese and even use chopsticks,
and some Chinese can say fluently English and know western manners as well.
Overall, Woman Warrior is a masterpiece
in the literature. It showed us the true situation of immigrants in USA at that
time. Personally, I think as immigrants, at least the first generation, should
never abandon our original cultural identity. Even though some changes are
necessary, we shall never forget who we are and where we come from.
I like your story about what you have experienced as an immigrant; I also have the same feeling when I had to talk English with others. From this point, Kingston did write a plot which can inspire other immigrants' empathy. I also agree with you that situation are definitely getting better these days due to the development of technology and communication; we are actually in a"global village" now; and the conflict between cultures may not be as severe as before. However, it is true that immigrants should never abandon their tradition, not they should forget where their "root" really is.
ReplyDeleteYour experience as the immigrant in America is very similar to mine and this topic reminds of me the period when I first came here. I feel sympathized with your and Maxine. However, It would better to put a focus on the textual analysis. For example, Maxine wrote out the little girl who first came America and had the "weird" thoughts about the life and the exotic environment. It would be better to have some of the evidences to relate to your own experience.
ReplyDelete