Insanity as defined by
dictionary.com is the “persistent mental disorder or derangement”. It is like a
severe mental illness. Something that this definition leaves out is that
insanity doesn’t necessarily only mean one’s mental health, it can also be
talking about something that is irrational or extremely foolish. Each person’s
view on something can be different. If one person finds something sane,
it’s safe to assume that another person can find the same thing insane.
As an American-born-Chinese, I learn
about my culture from my parents and other relatives. There are many beliefs
that we follow that are perfectly normal to us, yet can be seem as bizarre to
others. For example, my eldest sister told us younger ones many times that as a
baby, she has been burnt on her behind. After asking my grandmother, we learned
that doing so helped her rid of a serious fever she was fighting against. Another
cultural belief, or superstitious in this sense, is that our beds should never
be in line with the door. If your bed is directly across from the door, it is
said to resemble a coffin that is taken away feet first, and in
doing so, a ghost will drag you away at night. Though these beliefs are
commonly practiced by us, other cultures may find them extremely foolish or
irrational. In fact, I find the idea that using fire to cure fevers completely
absurd.
As seen above, what some find
sane, others find insane, and vice versa. This idea
is also seen in the play, “A Streetcar Named Desire” by Tennessee Williams. In this
play, we follow the life of Blanche, who moves in to stay with her sister
Stella and her husband Stanley. Throughout her stay, Blanche does a lot of
actions that make her seem crazier than normal. She lies about her age in hopes
to get together with a man, she always looks down on Stanley, and she doesn’t tell
Stella the truth about why she moved in with them: she got involved with a
student at her school and got kicked out. She may seem innocent, but she’s always
keeping things to herself and having weird thoughts. At first glance, one may
think Blanche is insane, but if we take into consideration her past, we may
find that maybe she isn't as crazy as we thought.
Blanche was married and was
happily in love with her husband until she found out he liked men. This came as
a huge shock to her, and after confronting him, her husband shot himself, which
shocked her even more. She then loses her family home and with no other place
to stay, lives with Stella. There, she learns that Stella’s husband doesn’t exactly
treat Stella with care, and this is not to Blanche’s liking. Moving a little
more forward, Blanche gets raped by Stanley. After having these tragic events
happen to her, it is no surprise that Blanche acts the way she does. She’s only
responding to what the world gives her, and these responses unfortunately make
her seem abnormal to others. But of course, the others do not see this as by
the end of the play, Blanche gets taken away by doctors, hinting that she’s
going to the mental hospital.
I find your topic about using fire to cure fever, and the location of our beds are very interesting. As a Chinese, I agree with your idea. Those cultural thoughts might be reasonable to the old Chinese people, but to us, they are kind of insane. The definition of insanity is always changing with time. What's more,I also agree with your idea that the death of Blanche's relatives, the lie of her husband,and the rape of Stanley make her insane. Actually,I think what she behaves after all this is reasonable. It's very hard for a woman to suffer all this sadness.
ReplyDeleteAs someone who is not Chinese I had never heard about these beliefS, and its extremely interesting to see how cultures differ. I completely agree with you on the fact that some cultures hold strange beliefs that to others might seem totally out of line with reality. By bringing up your own personal experience you helped build a strong argument for why Blanche wasn't insane. To further strengthen your essay the culture and ideals that were present in the 1920's should have been discussed in order to show under what standard Blanched was judged from.
ReplyDelete